This year several schools in Tasmania participated in the CBCA 2025 Shadow Judging program and this week’s post shares the experiences of students from The Hutchins School with three groups of students engaging with one of short list categories. Thanks to Anna Davidson for involving her school and providing insights into the value and outcomes of the work undertaken by these students.
This year, Hutchins was delighted to take part in the CBCA Shadow Judging program. With three enthusiastic teams across different age groups, our students embraced the challenge of reading, evaluating and voting on the CBCA shortlisted books.
Our youngest team, the ELC Lunchtime Book Club, explored the Early Childhood shortlist. Whilst One Little Dung Beetle was a favourite, after much discussion, this group cast their final vote for Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About the Tooth Fairy (and Some Things You Did Not)—a choice that sparked plenty of giggles and curiosity.
Overall, shadow judging gave our students the chance to see books through new eyes, strengthen their critical reading skills, and experience the joy of contributing to the wider literary community. We are grateful to the CBCA for providing this opportunity and cannot wait to take part again in 2026.
Meanwhile, a small but dedicated group of Year 4 and 5 readers tackled the Younger Reader shortlist. Meeting every Monday lunchtime with hot chocolate and biscuits, they worked their way through six shortlisted novels.
This group relished the challenge of reading within a set timeframe and often found themselves debating fiercely about which book should be crowned the winner. In the end, they chose Tigg and the Bandicoot Bushranger, deciding that while Fluff: Mess Up! was a strong contender (and group favourite), Tigg carried more literary weight and would stand the test of time.
As a teacher, it was inspiring to watch students move beyond personal preference and use the judging criteria to evaluate the books. Many students reflected that they enjoyed being pushed outside their comfort zones, encountering books they might not have chosen on their own.
To celebrate their efforts, some of our shadow judges enjoyed a special excursion to the Hobart Bookshop during Book Week, where they helped choose new books for our library collection. All groups also came together for a lively pizza party, watching the official CBCA Book of the Year announcements and comparing their decisions with other shadow judges across Australia. While not all their favourites won medals, students valued the experience of being part of a national conversation about books.
Overall, shadow judging gave our students the chance to see books through new eyes, strengthen their critical reading skills, and experience the joy of contributing to the wider literary community. We are grateful to the CBCA for providing this opportunity and cannot wait to take part again in 2026.
Anna Davidson
Head of Library, The Hutchins School
W: https://www.hutchins.tas.edu.au/
FB: https://www.facebook.com/TheHutchinsSchool
Editor’s note: What a rewarding and engaging activity for these students. You can find out more about the program on the CBCA website at https://shadowjudging.cbca.org.au/ including videos on this year’s winners and on how to get involved. Find out more: https://shadowjudging.cbca.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/2025-Shadow-Judging-Program-Information.pdf
